Lazygamer - Click here to go Home
ReviewsMenu SpacerFeaturesMenu SpacerVideosMenu SpacerPlaystation 3Menu SpacerXbox 360Menu SpacerNintendo WiiMenu SpacerPC GamingMenu SpacerHandheldsMenu SpacerSubmit News
Lazygamer Reviews
Final Fantasy XIII-2 9.0
The Darkness II 8.0
Soul Calibur V 8.0
Trine 2 8.0
Kirby's Adventure Wii 7.0
James Noir's Hollywood Crimes 3D 6.5
Dawn of Fantasy 1.0
Flux Family Secrets: The Ripple Effect 5.0
Anno 2070 8.0
Awakening: The Dreamless Castle 4.0
Over @ The Movies
Extras! Jean Dujardin is every villain in Hollywood, Marvel are being douches about Ghost Rider, The physics of film theme songs and Han never shot first? WTF?! Plus much more!
Welcome to The Extras! A daily dose of all the smaller movie related news, clips and just plain cool stuff that you might have missed!We begin with an amusing video from Funny Or Die, depicting Th
Christopher Plummer and Frank Langella get their boxing gloves out to star in a Muhammad Ali film
Whether you’re a fan of the puglisitic arts or not, everybody knows who Muhammed Ali is. A rock star of the boxing ring, the only thing quicker than his fists was his tongue, but things didn
Naomi Watts signs up to play Princess Diana
Well, the British sure do love their female politicians and royalty. Meryl Streep has been receiving accolads for her portrayal of Margaret Thatcher in the Iron Lady, which disappointingly was not
Prepare for a wetter, hotter, more American sequel
Back when it came out so many years, Wet hot American Summer was a flop at the box office. That doesn’t mean that the film wasn’t any good, but it the adventures of Bradley Cooper, Paul
Seeking a Friend For the End of the World trailer – Armageddon looks like quirky fun
Just  yesterday we showed you the poster to Steve Carrel and Keira Knightly’s oddball “end of the world”, romantic drama. Well now just a single day later, and the trailer has been
Latest News
In Other News – 10 February Weekend Edition
In Other News – 10 February Weekend Edition Well, I hope everyone is ready for a great weekend of gaming. We’ve got two major releases out this week, The Darkness 2 and Kingdoms of Amalur, so there’s bound to be something that will suit you
Lazygamer TV – Five Role-Playing Games to look forward to in 2012
Lazygamer TV – Five Role-Playing Games to look forward to in 2012 Shooters, adventure and sports games may be massively popular with gamers these days, but the humble role-playing genre has also evolved into a dominant force on the gaming scene. We take a look at fi
The Evopoints downloads of the week – 03/02/2012
The Evopoints downloads of the week – 03/02/2012 Confused by the deluge of downloadable gaming goodness? Don't be! Here's our guide to the hottest downloadable games on the internet this week.
Here’s what’s you’ll get when you buy Alan Wake on PC
Here’s what’s you’ll get when you buy Alan Wake on PC Alan Wake is headed to PC - and here's what you'll find in the box if you're patient enough to wait for a retail copy.
New screenshots mysteriously appear for ‘The Last Of Us’
New screenshots mysteriously appear for ‘The Last Of Us’ Mutants, marauders and the military, as the world of The Last Of Us looks like harsh and unforgiving future in these new screenshots.
Here are the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences’ best games of last year
Here are the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences’ best games of last year Time for more game of the year wards - but this one's from industry peers, so maybe Skyrim won't win. Pfft, yeah right.
So did Double Fine get their money?
So did Double Fine get their money? So did Double Fine raise enough money via Kickstarter yesterday? You know they did
Final Fantasy XIII-2 review – Help, there’s a Crux in my Paradox!
Final Fantasy XIII-2 review – Help, there’s a Crux in my Paradox! Que Serah, Serah. Is this the best Final Fantasy game ever?
Diablo 3’s coming before the end of June. Maybe.
Diablo 3’s coming before the end of June. Maybe. Activision has confirmed that Diablo III will be out before June. They haven't quite specifically stated which year though.
Activision says new Call of Duty looks “fantastic,” full of innovation
Activision says new Call of Duty looks “fantastic,” full of innovation Not only is there a new Call of Duty coming - obviously - but it's going to be full of innovation. I'll believe it when I see it.
Sony Looks to Implement “Project 10 Dollar” for 1st Party Titles Getting There
   August 24th, 2010 clock image 10:30 am

CashGrab

EA, you bastards! Look what you’ve done! at some point this generation, EA decided they weren’t making enough money from the sale of games, especially the sale of used games – where they make not a damned thing. They implemented “Project 10 Dollar,” an incentive of sorts to get people to purchase their games new instead of 2nd hand. New games would be sold with an “online pass” – a single use token, enabling basic features like online multiplayer.

2nd hand games would more often than not have this code missing – so purchasers of used games would have to pony up money for the privilege. Rival publisher THQ soon followed suit..and now it looks like Sony may do the same.

“On the principle of making online portions of the game available or unlocked from the disc-based release for a fee, we’re broadly supportive of that,” said SCEE president Andrew House to Gamesindustry.biz .”And we’re exploring actively the same option for our own content.

That’s not to say that they’ll be charging for online multiplayer, per se.

“In terms of just a charge for basic online play, that’s something that we have to talk about a lot more and we struggle with a little bit because we feel very vindicated and base a lot of the success of PSN today – a 70 per cent connection rate across consoles – on the fact that we’ve removed that major initial barrier to entry.”

I understand that publishers want to make the most money they can from the games they invest so heavily in, and that used game sales rob them of income – but I’d really prefer their incentives included new features and content, instead of just enabling basic features we’ve all become accustomed to.

Source : GI.Biz

Follow Geoffrey Tim on Twitter and like us on Facebook
General News | PS3
Previously on LazygamerNext on Lazygamer

Gamescom 2010: MotorStorm Apocalypse Trailer – Now this is a racing game

Hands on Preview: PES 2011


  • http://www.facebook.com/jannie.theron pantsula

    Every last drop…

  • RSA-Ace

    The second hand market is basically the same as piracy to publishers…

  • Bobby Kotick

    I would venture a guess that they consider the second hand market to be even worse than software piracy, hence the push to curb it. They have to be careful because this sort of behaviour is anti-consumer, and it’s only a matter of time before someone takes them to task for it.

    Anyway, EA is climbing back on my list of fail.

  • Bobby Kotick

    Sony can go on there as well.

  • D4RKL1NG

    What’s next? Paying in order to get the protective wrapping off your game? :pouty:

  • Bobby Kotick

    Exactly D4RKL1NG, this is getting ridiculous.

    By the way, you know what… THQ can go fuck themselves.
    http://kotaku.com/5620280/thq-buying-used-games-is-cheating

  • Hayted

    Oh Sony it ain’t so! :shocked:

  • Bonk is back in town

    There is absolutely no difference between 2nd hand sales and piracy whatsoever.

  • Bobby Kotick

    Please elaborate Bonk, because if you’re right, I’m off to go pirate some games.

  • Bobby Kotick

    Let’s see why software piracy is not the same as the second-hand market.

    For one thing, the Right of First Sale (which ultimately allows you to sell something 2nd hand) is crucial in capitalism and the free-market system, and it protects your right to rather buy a cheaper second-hand car (instead of a much more expensive newer model), or even buy a pre-owned DVD from your local Mr Video.

    The real reason why developers and publishers want to curb this market is ultimately to maximise profits (which in itself is not a big deal and completely understandable), however when it affects the right of the consumer, that’s where you start running into trouble. It is your right to want to buy an item at a cheaper price, and that holds especially true for a second hand item.

    The second-hand market is actually crucial to the whole system, without it, you actually remove secondary business between retailers and consumers, and you run the risk of biting the hand that feeds you.

    Any company that engages in this anti-consumer behaviour will be boycotted by me. It’s that simple. You may say, but Bobby you’re just one “elitist asshole” n00b, which is true, however consumer rights are universal, and there are thousands like me who are educated and consciousness consumers.

    Incidentally, and this relates to the push to curb piracy through DRM (which is also understandable), you are actually allowed to make copies of games, DVDs, CDs, books etc. as defined under copyright legislation, provided it’s for “fair use” (in other words, you’re not going to sell it, distribute it etc.). A lot is said about the UELAs and end user agreements in games, but they’re not as legally robust as you might think.

    Gamers and related consumers just haven’t had the need to test them.

  • Steve Hofmeyr

    I disagree.

    Second hand sales can provide gamers with funding to buy first hand games. Many people I know trade in lots of second hand games to get a discount.
    Further to that, having a strong second hand market for your product will increase it’s value to the consumer. How many games of R600 will you buy if you knew you can’t trade it in or sell it? How many cars would you buy if you can’t sell it second hand?
    They are shooting themselves in the foot IMO.

  • Steve Hofmeyr

    For once I absolutely agree with you Bobby. :shocked:

  • Bobby Kotick

    Are you disagreeing with me for being in support of the second hand market (which I notice you are as well) or are you merely disagreeing because you like to troll Bobby Kotick? :happy:

    But that’s exactly the point, the second market actually keeps gaming alive, because it allows many to sell and trade and buy new games.

    The developers and publishers are merely greedy in this regard.

  • Steve Hofmeyr

    I meant I disagreed with RSA-Ace. I’m in favour of second hand sales. Normally I would have taken the opportunity to troll you as per normal :angel: but this is an issue I feel very strongly about.

  • Bonk is back in town

    I think you and I have spoken about this before. Anyways here I go (I like to play devil’s advocate). Developers have always argued that games software is Work of a Movie’ and that ‘Work of a Movie’ has unrestricted rights. One therefore assume that any sales of second hand video games without the express approval of the copyright holder are illegal, because of the unrestricted distribution rights.

    Now the counter argument has always been that games software are not (Work of a Movie,) and that distribution rights of the patent lapses on the ‘first sale’. Fair enough I agree, but is it true that the second hand market increases sales, since it is argued that video games are marketed to children who would otherwise not be able to afford other games if they can’t sell their current games?

    Also if the distribution right of the patent falls away at the first sale then surely one is allowed upload your game to a p2p network. Or do people think you can’t back-up your game and then resell it?

  • Bobby Kotick

    You never really own the “rights to the game” but rather the right to make use of it (hence why the Berne convention and fair use principles still apply), therefore when you sell the game to a third party, the “right to make use of the game” transfers to them.

    Therefore, if you still have copies of the game you’re required to delete them because you no longer own the original, nor can you upload them to a p2p network, because it goes against “fair use”, since you’re now distributing the game.

  • Bonk is back in town

    And why would you delete them I may ask?

  • Bobby Kotick

    Same reason you wouldn’t torrent and download the pirated game to begin with. :happy:

  • http://www.lazygamer.co.za Geoffrey Tim

    Moral imperative.

  • Bonk is back in town

    Yes humans are known for their ‘fair use’ initiatives.

  • Bobby Kotick

    Perhaps, but not everyone who are in a position to commit a crime do so. Similarly, not every gamer with an internet connection have or will pirate a game.

    Anyway, I think we’ve gone off-topic a bit :P

  • Bobby Kotick

    My point is that “fair use” is protected under copyright legislation and the assertion that copying (of games, movies or music CDs) under “fair use” is illegal is incorrect. Whether people abide by the inherent limitations of “fair use” is really their prerogative, but if you’re pirating games (i.e. digitally distributing, selling etc.), you’re committing a crime.

    When it comes to the second-hand game market, the right of first sale merely means you have the right to sell and buy second-hand games, provided the same rights are conferred between the parties. In other words, a buyer of a second-hand item should not have less rights… etc. etc.

  • RSA-Ace

    I suppose the money still goes to new games. People that sell games are people that buy games.

    It still doesn’t balance out as much as I’d like though. I wouldn’t mind if developers could get a bit of the pie in second hand games. Have you looked at what american stores like GameStop make in the second hand market – it’s crazy…

  • Bonk is back in town

    I don’t think we have gone off-topic. I remember that Developers, Sony included argued about this in the mid-90s that the selling of second-hand games are illegal and tried to force wholesalers, shops etc to stop selling second hand games. Now we all know that they failed in forcing shops to stop selling second hand games, but I think devs do get upset when somebody else makes a profit on the back of another person’s work.

    If the right of first buyer is the same as the second then surely charging the second buyer is illegal in terms of Anti-Monopoly Law.

This post made me think about: , , ,
Socialise





Share






Subscribe to our RSS Feed

Lazygamer Staff
Gavin Mannion
Grumpy Smurf
twitter
Geoff Tim
Dancing Monkey
twitter
Darryn Bonthuys
Judas Iscariot
twitter
Nick de Bruyne
AFK
twitter


Content Sponsor


@ Tegato
Kodak to close down its camera manufacturing arms this year
Tesla unveils their new electric SUV
How Ok/Go made that ridiculously impressive music video
The Course of the Force – It’s like the Olympics, but with Light-sabers!
No Flash for Chrome for Android
@ Bandwidth Blog
Inside Vodacom’s App Store
Vodacom Slashes Data Pricing Up To 60% in Latest Promotion
Windows Phone 8 Details Revealed in Leaked Video
The ‘Agile Working’ Unilever Offices, Switzerland
How to setup your US iTunes account and buy vouchers